Formalizing Maximal Extractable Value: A Foundational Theory for Blockchain Security → Research

A modern, rectangular device with a silver metallic chassis and a clear, blue-tinted top cover is presented against a plain white background. Visible through the transparent top, a complex internal mechanism featuring a polished circular platter, gears, and an articulating arm suggests a precision data processing or storage unit

A complex, three-dimensional network structure is depicted, featuring a blurred blue tubular framework in the background and a sharp, transparent tubular network with metallic coiled connectors in the foreground. The coiled connectors act as nodes, linking the transparent tubes together

Briefing

The proliferation of Maximal Extractable Value (MEV) attacks has exposed a critical gap in blockchain theory → the absence of a rigorous, formal definition. This paper introduces a foundational theory of MEV, establishing a comprehensive model for smart contracts and adversarial capabilities, including a novel transaction deducibility framework. This theoretical advancement enables precise security proofs against MEV, offering a crucial tool for designing resilient blockchain architectures and mitigating economic vulnerabilities. Its implications extend to developing robust analysis tools for contract MEV-freedom, fostering more equitable and secure decentralized ecosystems.

A sophisticated, futuristic circular device with luminous blue elements and intricate metallic structures dominates the frame. A vibrant cloud of white mist, interspersed with brilliant blue granular particles, actively emanates from its central core, suggesting an advanced operational process

Context

Prior to this research, the understanding of Maximal Extractable Value (MEV) largely relied on empirical observations and partial definitions, leaving its theoretical foundations insufficiently established. This limitation meant that proving a smart contract was “MEV-free” lacked a rigorous basis, hindering the development of provably secure decentralized applications. The prevailing challenge involved characterizing the complex, identity-agnostic powers of MEV adversaries within a formal framework.

A complex, metallic sphere exhibits detailed, hexagonal facets and etched lines reminiscent of advanced circuit designs, enclosed by a framework of polished, metallic struts. This visual metaphor speaks to the intricate design of blockchain protocols and the secure cryptographic mechanisms essential for cryptocurrency operations

Analysis

The paper’s core contribution is a comprehensive formalization of MEV, built upon an abstract model of smart contracts and their state transitions. It introduces a sophisticated adversary model, notably defining “transaction deducibility” (κA(X)), which quantifies the information an adversary can infer by combining private knowledge with public mempool data. This mechanism fundamentally refines prior approaches by accounting for the full scope of adversarial information synthesis, allowing for the distinction between “legitimate” and “bad” MEV.

Furthermore, the concept of “universal MEV” is established, abstracting away specific actor identities and wealth through token redistribution to represent the maximal extractable gain by any arbitrary adversary. This framework enables the rigorous assessment of a contract’s MEV-freedom through formal proofs.

A sleek, metallic blue technological device with a prominent central circular mechanism is captured in a high-angle shot. A translucent, web-like substance appears to emanate from this core, spreading across its patterned surface

Parameters

Core Concept → Universal Maximal Extractable Value
New Mechanism → Transaction Deducibility Function (κA(X))
Authors → Massimo Bartoletti, Roberto Zunino
Publication Venue → arXiv (cs.CR)
Key Axiom → Axiom of Finite Tokens
Model Focus → Single-block MEV extraction
Primary Application → MEV-freedom proofs for smart contracts

A close-up view reveals a complex, textured metallic structure intricately intertwined with numerous smooth, dark blue cables. The metallic framework exhibits a weathered, almost corroded appearance, contrasting with the sleek, uniform conduits that pass through its openings

Outlook

This foundational MEV theory opens new avenues for rigorous security analysis, moving beyond empirical observations to provable guarantees for smart contracts. Future research will likely extend this model to address long-range MEV attacks and incorporate computational costs into adversarial knowledge, refining its real-world applicability. This framework will be instrumental in developing automated analysis tools, ultimately enabling the design of more secure and equitable decentralized finance protocols.

A close-up view reveals a multi-faceted, transparent object with sharp geometric edges, encasing a smooth, amorphous blue mass within its core. The interplay of light through the clear material highlights the vibrant blue interior and the intricate structure of the outer shell

Verdict

This formal theory of Maximal Extractable Value represents a critical advancement, providing the essential rigorous framework for constructing provably secure and economically resilient blockchain systems.

Signal Acquired from → arxiv.org