# DeFi Protocol Balancer Drained by Faulty Smart Contract Access Control Logic ∞ Security

**Published:** 2025-11-11
**Categories:** Security

---

![A sophisticated, blue and white mechanical assembly is depicted, partially encased in a frosted, crystalline substance with small bubbles. This intricate design suggests a high-performance system](https://incrypthos.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/Digital-Asset-Custody-Protocol-Layer-Immutable-Mechanism-Architecture.jpeg)

![A sleek, white, modular device emits a brilliant blue, energetic stream into a textured, luminous blue substance, creating frothy white patterns. The central apparatus, a sophisticated piece of blockchain infrastructure, appears to be actively engaging in a high-intensity digital asset processing operation](https://incrypthos.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/decentralized-finance-protocol-orchestrating-algorithmic-liquidity-synthesis.jpeg)

## Briefing

The Balancer V2 protocol suffered a catastrophic [smart contract exploit](https://incrypthos.com/news/smart-contract-exploit/), allowing an attacker to drain liquidity across seven distinct blockchain networks. The primary consequence is a significant erosion of trust in composable DeFi architectures and a mandatory, immediate halt of all affected pools to prevent further loss. This systemic event resulted from a critical access control flaw, with an estimated total loss of $128 million, making it one of the largest single-vector exploits of the year.

![The image displays a detailed close-up of translucent, blue-tinted internal mechanisms, featuring layered and interconnected geometric structures with soft edges. These components appear to be precisely engineered, showcasing a complex internal system](https://incrypthos.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/transparent-blockchain-protocol-architecture-cryptographic-layer-interoperability.jpeg)

## Context

The prevailing risk in complex DeFi architectures, specifically those using a centralized vault model for multiple pools, was the potential for a single point of failure within the core logic. Despite nine prior audits on the V2 vault system, the inherent complexity of [composable stable pools](https://incrypthos.com/news/composable-stable-pools/) and their custom balance management functions created an overlooked attack surface that persisted in production code. This highlights a persistent gap where formal verification has failed to capture subtle logic errors in highly integrated financial primitives.

![The image showcases a dark, metallic "X" structure with bright silver accents and internal blue illumination, surrounded by translucent blue tendrils. These ethereal blue tendrils organically flow around and through the central "X" symbol, visually representing the dynamic transfer of digital assets or oracle data within a sophisticated blockchain architecture](https://incrypthos.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/Blockchain-Interoperability-Nexus-Dynamic-Liquidity-Stream-Architecture.jpeg)

## Analysis

The exploit was executed by targeting a faulty [access control](https://incrypthos.com/news/access-control/) check within the manageUserBalance function of the V2 Composable Stable Pools. The attacker leveraged a logic error that failed to properly validate the msg.sender against the user-supplied op.sender parameter. This flaw permitted the execution of the UserBalanceOpKind.WITHDRAW_INTERNAL operation, effectively allowing the attacker to impersonate legitimate users and execute unauthorized internal withdrawals from the main vault. The attack succeeded because the contract’s logic did not enforce the necessary permission boundary before transferring funds from the protocol’s internal balances.

![A sophisticated, multi-component device showcases transparent blue panels revealing complex internal mechanisms and a prominent silver control button. The modular design features stacked elements, suggesting specialized functionality and robust construction](https://incrypthos.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/next-gen-secure-cryptographic-module-for-decentralized-storage.jpeg)

## Parameters

- **Total Funds Drained** ∞ $128 Million (The estimated maximum loss across all affected chains).

- **Vulnerability Type** ∞ [Access Control Flaw](https://incrypthos.com/news/access-control-flaw/) (A logic error in permission validation within the smart contract).

- **Affected Components** ∞ V2 Composable Stable Pools (The specific pool type containing the flawed balance management function).

- **Chains Impacted** ∞ Seven (Ethereum, Arbitrum, Base, Optimism, Polygon, Sonic, Berachain).

![A futuristic, silver and black hardware device is presented at an angle, featuring a prominent transparent blue section that reveals complex internal components. A central black button and a delicate, ruby-jeweled mechanism, akin to a balance wheel, are clearly visible within this transparent casing](https://incrypthos.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/blockchain-consensus-mechanism-visualized-secure-token-hardware.jpeg)

## Outlook

Immediate mitigation requires all users to withdraw liquidity from any remaining V2 Composable Stable Pools on all affected chains, as the vulnerability is systemic. The second-order effect is a high contagion risk for all protocols that have forked Balancer V2 code or utilize similar complex, multi-asset vault architectures. This incident will establish a new, higher standard for [formal verification](https://incrypthos.com/news/formal-verification/) on state-changing functions within core DeFi vaults, mandating a complete re-evaluation of all access control logic in composable systems.

![A close-up view presents a futuristic, metallic hardware device, partially adorned with granular frost, held by a white, textured glove. The device's open face reveals an intricate arrangement of faceted blue and silver geometric forms nestled within its internal structure](https://incrypthos.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/Cryptographic-Cold-Storage-Hardware-Mechanism-Securing-Digital-Assets.jpeg)

## Verdict

**The Balancer V2 exploit is a definitive signal that architectural complexity and reliance on external audits are insufficient defenses against subtle, high-impact [smart contract logic](https://incrypthos.com/news/smart-contract-logic/) flaws.**

smart contract logic, decentralized exchange, multi-asset pool, liquidity pool, vault architecture, permissionless withdrawal, smart contract function, composable DeFi, on-chain governance, emergency pause, white-hat bounty, token balance manipulation, internal accounting, protocol security Signal Acquired from ∞ <a href="https://crypto.news/berachain-recovers-12-8m-lost-balancer-exploit-2025/?utm_source=incrypthos.com&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=noo-engine.com" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">crypto.news</a> 

## Micro Crypto News Feeds

<a href="https://incrypthos.com/news/smart-contract-exploit/" class="glossary-item-box">

## smart contract exploit 

Definition ∞ A smart contract exploit is a security vulnerability within a self-executing contract that is intentionally leveraged by malicious actors. </a><a href="https://incrypthos.com/news/composable-stable-pools/" class="glossary-item-box">

## composable stable pools 

Definition ∞ Composable stable pools are liquidity pools in decentralized finance that consist of stablecoins and allow for flexible integration with other protocols. </a><a href="https://incrypthos.com/news/access-control/" class="glossary-item-box">

## access control 

Definition ∞ Access control dictates who or what can view or use resources within a digital system. </a><a href="https://incrypthos.com/news/access-control-flaw/" class="glossary-item-box">

## access control flaw 

Definition ∞ An access control flaw permits unauthorized users to perform actions they should not be able to. </a><a href="https://incrypthos.com/news/formal-verification/" class="glossary-item-box">

## formal verification 

Definition ∞ Formal verification is a mathematical technique used to prove the correctness of software or hardware systems. </a><a href="https://incrypthos.com/news/smart-contract-logic/" class="glossary-item-box">

## smart contract logic 

Definition ∞ Smart contract logic refers to the predefined, self-executing code embedded within a smart contract that dictates its behavior and conditions for execution. </a>

**Tags:** [Decentralized Finance Hack](https://incrypthos.com/news/decentralized-finance-hack/), [Withdrawal Function Flaw](https://incrypthos.com/news/withdrawal-function-flaw/), [Unauthorized Fund Transfer](https://incrypthos.com/news/unauthorized-fund-transfer/), [Access Control Vulnerability](https://incrypthos.com/news/access-control-vulnerability/), [Flash Loan Vector](https://incrypthos.com/news/flash-loan-vector/), [Composable Finance Risk](https://incrypthos.com/news/composable-finance-risk/)	

## Discover More

- 
### [GoPlus Suffers $169 Million Loss from Smart Contract and Insider Exploits](https://incrypthos.com/security/goplus-suffers-169-million-loss-from-smart-contract-and-insider-exploits/)
![Vibrant blue and silver mechanical components are thoroughly immersed in frothing water, symbolizing a rigorous protocol cleansing mechanism. The intricate gears and fins, reminiscent of validator node architecture, visually represent the precise transaction finality processes within a decentralized finance DeFi ecosystem. This visual metaphor highlights continuous smart contract auditing and liquidity pool maintenance, essential for robust blockchain network integrity. It ensures optimal throughput and operational security, reflecting the meticulous engineering behind reliable decentralized applications dApps.](https://incrypthos.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/Protocol-Cleansing-Mechanism-for-DeFi-Liquidity-Validation.jpeg)

A confluence of smart contract vulnerabilities and insider access enabled the unauthorized manipulation of liquidity pools, leading to significant capital drain.

- 
### [Formal Verification Framework for Secure Tokenized Financial Contracts](https://incrypthos.com/research/formal-verification-framework-for-secure-tokenized-financial-contracts/)
![A futuristic mechanism showcases a transparent shell encasing intricate silver labyrinthine patterns, illuminated by vibrant blue light. This internal structure visually interprets a cryptographic primitive within a blockchain architecture, symbolizing robust data integrity and a sophisticated consensus mechanism. The design suggests a secure enclave for smart contract execution, highlighting the computational complexity of decentralized autonomous organizations.](https://incrypthos.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/Cryptographic-Mechanism-Blockchain-Architecture-Interoperability-Layer-Interface.jpeg)

A new framework combines ACTUS and the B-Method to mathematically prove financial smart contract correctness, ensuring secure-by-design tokenized finance.

- 
### [Oracle Failures and Access Flaws Trigger $129 Million Multi-Chain DeFi Loss](https://incrypthos.com/web3/oracle-failures-and-access-flaws-trigger-129-million-multi-chain-defi-loss/)
![A central white spherical object, resembling a blockchain node or DAO core, features a dark, precise aperture. It is surrounded by an intricate array of vibrant blue, translucent crystalline structures, abstractly representing data shards or cryptographic keys in a distributed ledger. These elements extend outwards, illustrating the complex interconnections within a consensus mechanism or Web3 protocol, emphasizing the secure and transparent nature of transaction verification across an immutable ledger.](https://incrypthos.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/Blockchain-Core-Cryptographic-Node-Consensus-Mechanism-Sharding.jpeg)

The cascading $129M loss from oracle manipulation and faulty access controls re-centers the DeFi industry on infrastructure risk and security rigor.

- 
### [Formalizing MEV: Rigorous Model for Provably Secure Blockchain Architectures](https://incrypthos.com/research/formalizing-mev-rigorous-model-for-provably-secure-blockchain-architectures/)
![A transparent, faceted component connects to a larger, segmented cylindrical structure emitting a vibrant blue energy field. This visual metaphor represents the intricate mechanisms of decentralized ledger technology, possibly illustrating cross-chain communication protocols or the fusion of disparate blockchain networks. The design evokes concepts like atomic swaps, sharding, and the secure, trustless exchange of digital assets within the broader cryptocurrency ecosystem. It symbolizes the convergence of different cryptographic primitives to achieve enhanced scalability and interoperability for future dApps and DeFi protocols.](https://incrypthos.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/Decentralized-Ledger-Interoperability-Protocol-Nexus-Cryptographic-Fusion.jpeg)

This research introduces a formal, abstract model for Maximal Extractable Value, enabling systematic analysis and the development of provably secure blockchain protocols.

- 
### [Zero-Knowledge Proof of Training Secures Federated Consensus](https://incrypthos.com/research/zero-knowledge-proof-of-training-secures-federated-consensus/)
![A sophisticated close-up reveals interconnected metallic and translucent blue components, evoking advanced blockchain infrastructure. Precision-engineered silver elements interlock, suggesting a robust decentralized network architecture. A prominent, vibrant blue conduit appears to facilitate a data stream, vital for transaction processing and protocol execution. This visual metaphor highlights the intricate mechanics of a distributed ledger technology DLT system, where nodes communicate seamlessly. The metallic surfaces, possibly hardware wallets or mining rig components, reflect light, emphasizing the system's cryptographic security and algorithmic precision in maintaining ledger immutability.](https://incrypthos.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/blockchain-protocol-data-stream-decentralized-infrastructure-module.jpeg)

Research introduces ZKPoT consensus, leveraging zk-SNARKs to cryptographically verify machine learning contributions without exposing private training data or model parameters.

- 
### [OWASP Identifies Top 10 Smart Contract Vulnerabilities for 2025](https://incrypthos.com/security/owasp-identifies-top-10-smart-contract-vulnerabilities-for-2025/)
![A sophisticated, compact hardware wallet, featuring a frosted, translucent blue chassis suggesting advanced cold storage capabilities. A prominent clear blue dome encapsulates a liquid-like substance, symbolizing a secure enclave for cryptographic keys and sensitive seed phrase data. The device's robust design implies immutable ledger protection for digital assets, ensuring non-custodial ownership. Its sleek form factor and subtle metallic accents highlight next-generation blockchain security protocols, vital for decentralized finance DeFi participants. This secure element facilitates multi-factor authentication and private key management, safeguarding against unauthorized transaction signing.](https://incrypthos.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/next-gen-cold-storage-hardware-wallet-digital-asset-security.jpeg)

The OWASP Smart Contract Top 10 for 2025 highlights persistent architectural flaws, posing systemic risk to decentralized finance protocols and user assets.

- 
### [SEC Staff Expands Qualified Custodian Definition for Institutional Crypto Asset Custody](https://incrypthos.com/regulation/sec-staff-expands-qualified-custodian-definition-for-institutional-crypto-asset-custody/)
![A transparent, fluid-filled vessel displays dynamic blue liquid and effervescent bubbles, set within a sophisticated metallic and dark blue framework. This visual metaphor illustrates the intricate processes of a smart contract execution. The swirling blue elements symbolize the transaction flow and data packets within a decentralized network. Bubbles represent individual cryptocurrency transactions or oracle data inputs, actively processed within a secure on-chain protocol environment. The robust, high-precision base suggests a layer-2 scaling solution or an enterprise blockchain infrastructure, emphasizing system integrity and efficiency in digital asset management.](https://incrypthos.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/Smart-Contract-Execution-Flow-Dynamics-Interface.jpeg)

The No-Action Letter provides a crucial regulatory pathway for Registered Investment Advisers to custody digital assets with state-chartered trust entities.

- 
### [Zero-Knowledge Proof of Training Secures Decentralized Federated Learning](https://incrypthos.com/research/zero-knowledge-proof-of-training-secures-decentralized-federated-learning/)
![A detailed close-up reveals a sophisticated, multi-layered mechanism featuring polished metallic blue components and intricate translucent structures. The central blue element, possibly a core cryptographic primitive, is integrated with a clear, gear-like module suggesting verifiable computation and on-chain transparency. Its complex design evokes advanced consensus mechanisms or protocol layer interactions within a distributed ledger technology framework. The precision engineering highlights the robust architecture required for secure, high-performance transaction finality in a decentralized network.](https://incrypthos.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/Cryptographic-Primitives-Engine-for-Decentralized-Consensus-Verifiable-Computation.jpeg)

ZKPoT consensus leverages zk-SNARKs to cryptographically verify model performance, solving the privacy-efficiency trade-off in decentralized AI.

- 
### [Zero-Knowledge Proof of Training Secures Private Decentralized Federated Learning](https://incrypthos.com/research/zero-knowledge-proof-of-training-secures-private-decentralized-federated-learning/)
![An intricate mechanical assembly showcases the complex internal workings of a conceptual Ethereum Virtual Machine protocol engine. Metallic silver and deep blue components form a robust Web3 infrastructure, featuring visible gears and precision-engineered parts. A prominent Ethereum logo, embedded within a blue frame, signifies the core smart contract execution environment. This detailed representation illustrates the underlying consensus mechanism and cryptographic primitives essential for robust decentralized ledger technology and efficient Layer 2 scaling solutions, symbolizing the meticulous engineering behind digital asset operations.](https://incrypthos.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/ethereum-virtual-machine-protocol-engine-core-mechanics.jpeg)

ZKPoT consensus validates machine learning model performance cryptographically, eliminating privacy trade-offs and centralizing risks in decentralized AI.

**Tags:** [Access Control Vulnerability](https://incrypthos.com/news/access-control-vulnerability/), [Composable Finance Risk](https://incrypthos.com/news/composable-finance-risk/), [Cross-Chain Contagion](https://incrypthos.com/news/cross-chain-contagion/), [Decentralized Finance Hack](https://incrypthos.com/news/decentralized-finance-hack/), [DeFi Protocol Security](https://incrypthos.com/news/defi-protocol-security/), [Flash Loan Vector](https://incrypthos.com/news/flash-loan-vector/), [Internal Balance Manipulation](https://incrypthos.com/news/internal-balance-manipulation/), [Multi-Chain Liquidity](https://incrypthos.com/news/multi-chain-liquidity/), [Precision Error](https://incrypthos.com/news/precision-error/), [Reentrancy Risk](https://incrypthos.com/news/reentrancy-risk/), [Smart Contract Audit Failure](https://incrypthos.com/news/smart-contract-audit-failure/), [Smart Contract Exploit](https://incrypthos.com/news/smart-contract-exploit/), [Unauthorized Fund Transfer](https://incrypthos.com/news/unauthorized-fund-transfer/), [Vault Security Model](https://incrypthos.com/news/vault-security-model/), [Withdrawal Function Flaw](https://incrypthos.com/news/withdrawal-function-flaw/)

---

## Raw Schema Data

```json
{
    "@context": "https://schema.org",
    "@type": "BreadcrumbList",
    "itemListElement": [
        {
            "@type": "ListItem",
            "position": 1,
            "name": "Home",
            "item": "https://incrypthos.com"
        },
        {
            "@type": "ListItem",
            "position": 2,
            "name": "Security",
            "item": "https://incrypthos.com/security/"
        },
        {
            "@type": "ListItem",
            "position": 3,
            "name": "DeFi Protocol Balancer Drained by Faulty Smart Contract Access Control Logic",
            "item": "https://incrypthos.com/security/defi-protocol-balancer-drained-by-faulty-smart-contract-access-control-logic/"
        }
    ]
}
```

```json
{
    "@context": "https://schema.org",
    "@type": "Organization",
    "@id": "http://incrypthos.com#organization",
    "name": "Incrypthos",
    "url": "http://incrypthos.com",
    "description": "Incrypthos Crypto News Engine is a proprietary language model designed specifically for the cryptocurrency domain. It operates 24/7 to ingest, analyze, and synthesize information from hundreds of global sources. Its core function is to discern the signal from the noise, reconstructing complex news and research into structured, objective summaries. Every article is generated by this engine and includes a direct link to the original source to ensure full transparency.",
    "email": "info@incrypthos.com",
    "logo": {
        "@type": "ImageObject",
        "url": "https://incrypthos.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/Incrypthos.svg"
    }
}
```

```json
{
    "@context": "https://schema.org",
    "@type": "Article",
    "mainEntityOfPage": {
        "@type": "WebPage",
        "@id": "https://incrypthos.com/security/defi-protocol-balancer-drained-by-faulty-smart-contract-access-control-logic/"
    },
    "headline": "DeFi Protocol Balancer Drained by Faulty Smart Contract Access Control Logic \u221e Security",
    "description": "A logic flaw in V2 Composable Stable Pools enabled unauthorized internal withdrawals, exposing multi-chain liquidity to systemic risk. \u221e Security",
    "url": "https://incrypthos.com/security/defi-protocol-balancer-drained-by-faulty-smart-contract-access-control-logic/",
    "datePublished": "2025-11-11T03:16:21+00:00",
    "dateModified": "2025-11-11T03:16:29+00:00",
    "articleSection": [
        "Security"
    ],
    "author": {
        "@id": "http://incrypthos.com#organization"
    },
    "publisher": {
        "@id": "http://incrypthos.com#organization"
    },
    "image": {
        "@type": "ImageObject",
        "url": "https://incrypthos.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/transparent-on-chain-visibility-device-for-cryptographic-primitive-execution.jpeg",
        "caption": "The image displays a futuristic, angled device featuring a translucent blue lower casing that reveals intricate internal mechanisms, complemented by a sleek silver metallic top panel and a dark, reflective screen. Prominent silver buttons and a circular dial are integrated into its design, emphasizing interactive control and robust construction. This innovative design serves as a compelling visual metaphor for the operational transparency inherent in distributed ledger technology, where cryptographic primitives execute smart contract logic. The visible internal components symbolize the complex consensus mechanisms driving blockchain networks, while the secure, metallic exterior suggests the robust security protocols of a hardware wallet or cold storage solution. Its ergonomic form and accessible controls could represent user-friendly interfaces for on-chain governance or multi-signature authentication. This device encapsulates the blend of visibility and security crucial for managing digital assets and facilitating decentralized finance DeFi within institutional-grade infrastructure, highlighting the intersection of advanced engineering and blockchain innovation."
    },
    "keywords": [
        "Access Control Vulnerability",
        "Composable Finance Risk",
        "Cross-Chain Contagion",
        "Decentralized Finance Hack",
        "DeFi Protocol Security",
        "Flash Loan Vector",
        "Internal Balance Manipulation",
        "Multi-Chain Liquidity",
        "Precision Error",
        "Reentrancy Risk",
        "Smart Contract Audit Failure",
        "Smart Contract Exploit",
        "Unauthorized Fund Transfer",
        "Vault Security Model",
        "Withdrawal Function Flaw"
    ]
}
```


---

**Original URL:** https://incrypthos.com/security/defi-protocol-balancer-drained-by-faulty-smart-contract-access-control-logic/
